A Long-Running Legal Battle
E. Jean Carroll's legal battle against Donald Trump continues to make headlines, as her lawyers fight to uphold an $83 million damages verdict in the US Supreme Court. The case, which began in 2019, has seen numerous twists and turns, with Trump repeatedly denying wrongdoing and employing various legal strategies to avoid liability.
The Allegations and Verdict
Carroll, a journalist and author, accused Trump of sexually assaulting her in a Manhattan department store dressing room several decades ago. Her allegation went public in a 2019 New York magazine article, an excerpt from her book, "What Do We Need Men For? A Modest Proposal."
In January 2024, a jury found in Carroll's favor, awarding her $5 million in damages for sexual abuse and defamation. This was the first trial, which focused on the merits of the case. A second trial, held to determine the amount of damages, resulted in an $83 million award for Carroll.
Trump's Immunity Argument
Trump's legal team has argued that presidential immunity protects him from liability for conduct during his time in office, including statements made in 2019 in which he called Carroll a liar. They claim that the Supreme Court's intervention is necessary to "protect not the President himself, but the institution of the Presidency."
"After all, the specter of personal liability for official conduct, in an amount that would bankrupt virtually any other President, will chill the exercise of executive power by future Presidents," they stated.
Carroll's Response
Carroll's legal team, led by attorney Roberta Kaplan, has strongly opposed Trump's appeal. They argue that the verdict has been upheld by lower courts and that Trump's request for Supreme Court review is unwarranted.
"For seven years – through five appeals, eight stay motions, and six days of trial – Ms. Carroll has litigated this case in the face of petitioner’s increasingly vicious accusations and thousands of threats of death and sexual violence from his followers," they wrote.
They further emphasized the impact of Trump's defamatory statements, stating that Carroll was "instantly and continuously attacked on Twitter and Facebook and in emails," including threats of sexual violence and physical harm.
A Pattern of Appeals
One commenter noted the repetitive nature of these legal proceedings:
"How many times can this go on? ... Per the article, this is another new attempt by the Orange Rapist to get out of paying the damages."
Another commenter expressed frustration with Trump's tactics:
"Trump is making zero effort. He sends lawyers to keep the case going to exhaust the other side of funds. That's been his way for decades."
The Impact and Future
The case has significant implications for the presidency and the potential liability of future presidents. Trump's legal team argues that the verdict, if upheld, would set a dangerous precedent and "chill the exercise of executive power."
As one commenter put it:
"The average American loses a court decision, they have a right to appeal, they lose the appeal. Unless information comes up that deserves another look, you’re done. Trump loses a court decision, he has the right to appeal, he loses the appeal, he refuses to accept the decision... Yup, looks fair and balanced to me."
The Supreme Court's decision will be crucial in determining the outcome of this high-profile case and the potential impact on presidential immunity and liability.